One of the clearest and most consistent messages to emerge from maternity reviews over the last decade is remarkably simple:
Families often knew something was wrong, but they were not listened to.
From Morecambe Bay and East Kent to Shrewsbury and Telford, and most recently Nottingham, the same themes continue to appear. Women, families and carers raised concerns. Opportunities to act were missed. Communication broke down. Voices that should have been heard were overlooked.
In response to the findings of the latest Ockenden Review into maternity services at Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust, the Government has announced that Martha’s Rule will be extended to all maternity and neonatal services across England. The initiative will enable parents and families to request an urgent review if they believe a mother or baby’s condition is deteriorating and their concerns are not being addressed. [gov.uk], [england.nhs.uk]
Read more:
https://www.gov.uk/government/news/marthas-rule-extended-to-all-maternity-services [gov.uk]
What is Martha’s Rule?
Martha’s Rule was developed following the tragic death of Martha Mills, whose family repeatedly raised concerns about her deteriorating condition while she was in hospital. A coroner later found that Martha would probably have survived had she been transferred to intensive care sooner. Her story became a catalyst for change across the NHS. [england.nhs.uk], [england.nhs.uk]
At its heart, Martha’s Rule recognises a fundamental truth:
Patients, families and carers are often the first to notice when something is wrong.
The initiative gives families a clear route to seek a rapid review from another clinical team if they believe concerns about a patient’s deteriorating condition are not being acted upon. [england.nhs.uk], [england.nhs.uk]
Leading the Way Locally
Many maternity services already have similar escalation processes in place under names such as Call 4 Concern.
We would like to recognise the work of the Royal Berkshire Maternity Unit, which has been ahead of the curve in providing families with a clear mechanism to escalate concerns. Through its Call 4 Concern process, the Trust has embraced the same principles that underpin Martha’s Rule: empowering women, families and carers to speak up when something does not feel right.
This is an important patient safety measure and demonstrates a commitment to listening to the people who know their loved ones best.
A Safety Net, Not a Substitute
The expansion of Martha’s Rule is undoubtedly positive.
It provides an additional safeguard when patients and families feel their concerns are not being heard. It places greater value on lived experience and acknowledges that safety is strengthened when people are empowered to speak up. [england.nhs.uk], [gov.uk]
But it also raises an important question:
Why should people need a separate route to be heard in the first place?
The ultimate goal must be a healthcare culture where concerns are listened to the first time they are raised, rather than only after an escalation process is triggered.
Martha’s Rule should be viewed as a safety net, not a replacement for compassionate communication, good clinical practice and genuine partnership with patients and families.
Public Voice is a Patient Safety Tool
Too often, patient and public involvement is viewed as a “nice to have” rather than an essential component of safe care.
The lessons from every maternity review tell us otherwise.
Listening to women and families is not about customer service. It is about preventing harm, identifying deterioration earlier and improving outcomes.
Every escalation begins with someone saying:
“I’m worried.”
Those words should never be dismissed.
Families see changes that may not yet appear in observations. Partners notice when something feels different. Parents know their babies. Women know their own bodies.
When healthcare systems create environments where concerns can be raised safely and acted upon quickly, lives can be saved.
From Tokenism to Partnership
The introduction of Martha’s Rule across maternity and neonatal services represents an important shift in culture.
It sends a clear message that the voices of women, families and carers matter.
However, real change will come when public voice is embedded in how services are designed, delivered and improved, not just when things go wrong.
Patient voice is not an add-on to healthcare.
It is not a consultation exercise.
It is not tokenistic.
It is an essential part of safe, effective and compassionate care.
The lesson from every maternity review is clear:
Listening saves lives.
And that is why Martha’s Rule matters.
#MarthasRule #Call4Concern #RoyalBerkshireMaternity #MaternitySafety #PatientVoice #ListeningSavesLives #PublicVoice #InsightToImpact #TokenisticNoMore